nail your paint color: how to choose the perfect shade without regret
Hey there! Just a heads up—some of the links in this post are affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you make a purchase through them. It doesn’t cost you anything extra (promise!), but it helps me keep this blog up and running so I can continue sharing budget-friendly decor tips with you. I only recommend products and services I genuinely love and think you will too. Thanks for supporting Nesting Nook—you’re the best!
So, you're ready to give your space a fresh new look, but the thought of picking a paint color has you stressing out? We've all been there. Standing in front of that giant wall of paint chips, wondering how on earth you're supposed to pick the one that's going to transform your room into the cozy, stylish haven you’re dreaming of. But don’t worry—I’ve got you covered.
Let’s dive into how to choose the perfect paint color, avoid the common pitfalls, and get it right the first time.
Understanding Undertones: The Secret Sauce
Ever painted a room only to realize the “perfect gray” you picked now looks like baby blue? The culprit? Undertones. Every color has an underlying hue that can shift depending on the light and surroundings. For example, that warm beige might suddenly look pink in your room because of its undertones. The key here? Know thy undertones. When you're picking a color, grab a few different swatches and compare them. You’ll start to see which ones lean a little warmer (think yellow or red undertones) and which are cooler (blue or green undertones). Understanding this little detail will save you from major paint regret.
Pro Tip: If you’re feeling lost in a sea of undertones, grab some paint samples to test on your wall (more on that in a sec). Visit your closest home depot or Lowe’s and grab a couple of paint pots. They’re not free, but it’s worth testing it out before you buy an entire gallon of the wrong paint color.
Test, Test, and Test Some More
You’ve got your swatches narrowed down—now it’s time for the ultimate test: how they look in your space. Here’s the deal: paint can look completely different depending on your room’s lighting. Natural light, artificial light, morning light, evening light—it all plays a role. Before you commit, grab some sample pots of your top contenders and paint swatches directly on your wall. Live with them for a few days. Watch how the color changes throughout the day and how it vibes with your furniture and decor.
Coordinate with What You Already Have
Now that you’ve seen your paint choices in action, it’s time to think about how they play with your existing decor. Your paint color should complement—not compete—with your furniture, flooring, and accents. If you’re working with a lot of warm tones, lean into that with a warm paint color that enhances those hues. Got cool-toned furniture? Stick with colors that keep that vibe consistent.
Pro Tip: Don’t forget to consider your trim, doors, and ceilings. A crisp white trim can make a bold wall color pop, while a coordinating ceiling color can tie everything together.
Light It Up
Lighting is everything when it comes to paint. Natural light will always be your BFF, but let’s be real—not every room is blessed with it. For those darker spaces, consider your artificial lighting. Warm bulbs will bring out those warmer undertones, while cool bulbs will emphasize cooler shades. If your room doesn’t get much light, avoid dark colors that can make it feel smaller and more closed-in.
Pro Tip: Want to really control the mood? Check out smart bulbs that let you adjust the warmth and brightness. It’s like mood lighting, but for your paint. The control they allow you to have on the ambiance of your room is worth it.
Finish Strong: Choosing the Right Paint Finish
Alright, so you’ve got the color down—now let’s talk finish. This might seem like a small detail, but trust me, it’s a game-changer. Here’s the rundown:
Matte: Perfect for low-traffic areas like bedrooms. It’s got a soft, velvety look, but it’s not the easiest to clean.
Eggshell/Satin: Your go-to for living rooms and hallways. It’s got a bit of sheen and is more durable.
Semi-Gloss/Gloss: Ideal for trim, doors, and areas that need to stand up to some wear and tear. Plus, it adds a nice contrast if your walls are matte.
Choosing the right finish adds another layer of dimension to your space. If you’re stuck, I’ve linked a handy finish guide to help you out.
Trendy vs. Timeless: Do You, But Do It Smart
We all love a good trend, but when it comes to paint, it’s a commitment. If you’re in love with that trendy deep navy or rich emerald, go for it! But if you’re worried about getting tired of it in a year, consider using trendy colors in smaller doses—like on an accent wall or in accessories that are easier to swap out. That way, your walls stay fresh, but you can still keep up with the latest looks.
Handling Paint Regret (Yes, It’s a Thing)
So, you’ve painted the whole room, stepped back, and...you’re not feeling it. It happens to the best of us. But don’t freak out. There are ways to salvage the situation:
Add Complementary Colors: Sometimes all it takes is a few throw pillows or a rug that ties the whole look together.
Adjust Your Lighting: Remember how light can change a color? Try tweaking your lighting before you break out the paintbrush again.
When All Else Fails, Repaint: If you really can’t live with it, there’s no shame in starting over. It’s better to love your space than to settle for something that doesn’t feel right.
Pro Tip: A good primer is your best friend when repainting. It’ll cover up the old color and give you a fresh start.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right paint color is more art than science, but with these tips, you’re well on your way to nailing it. Take your time, test your options, and don’t be afraid to go bold—just make sure it’s a color that makes you smile every time you walk into the room.
Ready to get started? Check out the products and tools I’ve recommended below to make your paint project as smooth (and fun) as possible. Happy painting!
xo
————
Sounds obvious, but I’ve tried painting many times without painters tape because I think I’m soooo good at painting - I’m not and every time it was a mess. Learn from my mistakes and pick up these tools to ensure it will be mess free. Don’t skimp on covering the floor - My landlord hated me.
